Choosing a Business Entity
Businesses can be set up in a variety of different forms including:
- Corporations
- Limited Liability Companies
- Sole Proprietorship
Each type of entity has its own unique advantages and disadvantages. One of the most
significant considerations is how the business entity will be taxed.
(See Tax Treatment of
Business Entities).
A business can usually change its legal structure after it is formed. However, changing the
business structure sometimes causes tax liabilities that could have been avoided by initially
choosing the best business form. Consequently, deciding on the form or structure of the
business is one of the first important decisions the business owner makes.
The choice of the business structure should be made in consultation with your attorney,
accountant, or other competent business adviser. These professionals can also help you with:
- Advise on the requirements of various statutes
- Advise on trademark and copyright issues
- Advise on non-compete issues
- Advise on employment issues
- Advise on tax issues
- Assistance in preparation of a business plan
Obtaining competent advice and services early in the process of embarking on a business venture
can save both time and money by avoiding costly mistakes.
Corporations
A corporation is legal entity wholly separate and apart from its owners (the shareholders or
"stockholders"). A Louisiana corporation is formed by filing the articles of incorporation with
the Louisiana Secretary of State. The articles of incorporation must contain: the name of the
corporation, the purpose or purposes for which the corporation is formed, or that the corporation
can engage in any lawful activity allowed by Louisiana law, the duration of the corporation or
that it has a perpetual existence, and the number of shares the corporation shall have authority to
issue.
The document may also include:
- provisions regarding corporate management
- provisions indemnifying the corporation's directors and officers
- provisions limiting director and officer liability, and
- provisions restricting the transfer of shares.
Once the articles are filed they become part of the public records and anyone can obtain the
information in the articles of incorporation.
Corporations usually have a set of bylaws which govern how the corporation is run. These
bylaws are not generally a public record. The bylaws are adopted by the shareholders who
formed the corporation or by the board of directors elected by the shareholders. The bylaws can
later be changed by a vote of the shareholders or the directors, depending upon the provisions of
the articles of incorporation or the bylaws themselves.
Corporations enjoy many advantages as a business form. Perhaps the most important advantage
is that a corporation's stockholders, directors, and officers are not liable for the debts or other
obligations of the corporation. Usually they are liable only for debts or other obligations which
they have personally guaranteed or that result from their own negligence or misconduct.
Because it is a separate entity, a corporation is not terminated or dissolved upon the death or
departure of a shareholder. As a result, upon the death of a shareholder the assets of the
corporation are not tied up in the shareholders estate.
Smaller corporations are often "closely-held," that is, the shares are owned by a small group of
shareholders and have restrictions on transfer. The shareholders of smaller corporations
commonly enter into a "buy-sell" agreement which limit the sale of the shares. This type of
agreement ensures that if the shareholder wishes to sell his shares they will be offered back to the
existing shareholders or the corporation.
Limited Liability Companies
A limited liability company ( "LLC") is an unincorporated business entity that has the best
characteristics of corporations and partnerships. The owners of an LLC are called members
instead of stockholders or partners.
Like a corporation, an LLC shields its members from personal liability for the debts and
obligations of the business, and like a partnership, the income and losses from the LLC are
usually not taxed at the entity level, but instead are taxed at the individual level.
An LLC is formed by filing "articles of organization" with the Louisiana Secretary of State. The
members of an LLC usually enter into an operating agreement that regulates how the LLC is
governed. The provisions of the operating agreement can provide for how the LLC will be
managed, what happens upon the death of a member, how a member's interest can be transferred,
and it can provide for a "buy-sell" agreement among its members.
An LLC can have an unlimited number of members and there are no restrictions on the type of
persons who can be members. Some states do not allow one person LLCs , however, Louisiana
does allow an LLC to have only one member. Additionally, an LLC can have more than one
class of equity interest, as well as wholly owned subsidiaries whose assets, liabilities, and
operating results are treated independently from those of its LLC parent.
One advantage of an LLC over a corporation is that there is more flexibility in management. For
example, an LLC can be managed in the following ways:
- Solely by its members
- By only one member who is designated as the "managing member"
- By its members and a management committee serving in a function similar to the board of directors
Further, an LLC, unlike a Sub Chapter S corporation, can allocate profits, losses, and
distributions disproportionate to the percentage of equity interest held in the LLC.
(See Tax Treatment of Business Entities)
Because an LLC combines insulation from personal liability like a corporation with the tax
advantages and managerial flexibility of a partnership, it will, in most cases, be the entity of
choice for a new business. Moreover, using the LLC is not an impediment to raising capital as
the LLC gives equity owners the same protection from liability they would have received as
equity owners of a corporation.
Tax Treatment of Business Entities
Corporations
The federal tax treatment of corporations is governed by the Internal Revenue Code. Attorneys,
accountants, and other professionals usually refer to the types of corporations and their tax
treatment according to the provision of the tax code that applies to that type of corporation. For
tax purposes, there are two main types of corporations:
- "C" corporations
- "S" corporations
A "C" corporation is taxed at the entity level. By taxing at the entity level the corporation itself
must pay income taxes. Income that has been taxed at the entity level will again be taxed if, and
when, it is distributed as dividends to shareholders. This double taxation is perhaps the single
greatest disadvantage to operating as a "C" corporation. However, "S" corporations may avoid
much of this double taxation.
Despite double taxation, corporations do enjoy some tax-related advantages when compared to
other business forms. Because the corporation and the owners each pay income taxes it may be
advantageous to use a corporation in a business that requires capital to be retained to fund the
purchases of equipment, machinery, and other assets. In this case the corporation and the
owners combined income is divided between two taxpayers, thus potentially making the overall
marginal tax rate lower.
For example, if a capital-intensive business is conducted as a sole
proprietorship, an L.L.C, or a partnership, the owners would be individually taxed (possibly at
the 39.6% top rate) on the earnings, even if they had to leave all or part of these earnings in the
business to fund the acquisition of machinery and equipment. However, a corporation is not
required to distribute earnings to its shareholders and can use them for corporate purposes. If the
corporation has a lower marginal tax rate than the owners then more dollars are available for
capital acquisitions. For example, if the corporation's income is less than $50,000.00 its tax rate
is 15%, if its income is over $50,000.00, but less than $75,000.00, its marginal tax rate is 25%,
and if its income is over $75,000.00, but less than $100,000.00 its marginal tax rate is 34%. If
these tax rates are lower than the owner's marginal tax rate then there is more money available
for capital expansion.
There are, however, limitations on the amount of earnings a corporation can accumulate before it
must distribute them to shareholders or use them in the business. Otherwise, the corporation may
face an additional tax on the accumulated earnings.
"S" Corporations
Certain small companies with no more than 75 shareholders and meeting certain requirements
(only one class of common stock and only certain types of shareholders) can be taxed as an S
corporation. An S corporation is also limited in the shares it may own in another S corporation.
If a corporation elects to be taxed as an S corporation and qualifies, it will be taxed in a manner
similar to a partnership or limited liability company. That is, the income, losses, and gains will
be passed through directly to the shareholders and there will be no tax "at the entity level."
Tax Treatment of Limited Liability Companies
Unless it elects to be taxed as a corporation, the tax treatment of a limited liability company
("LLC") is the same as that of a partnership or sole proprietorship. That is, the profits and losses
are passed through to the members of the LLC and there is no tax at the entity level. In such a
case the LLC is a tax reporting entity, it files a tax return, but it does not pay any taxes. Instead,
the taxes are paid by the members of the LLC. Each member of an LLC should receive an IRS
Form K-1 which will set forth the members profits and losses from the LLC. The members use
the IRS Form K-1 in preparing their own tax returns and accounting for their income or loss from
the LLC.
Tax treatment of Sole Proprietorships
A sole proprietorship does not have any existence separate and apart from the individual sole
proprietor. As a result, any income that is earned from the business is considered the income of
the individual owner. The sole proprietorship itself is not separately taxed, rather the sole
proprietor reports business income and expenses on his own tax return and pays taxes
accordingly. The sole proprietor's business income and expenses are usually reported on
Schedule C of the taxpayers individual federal income tax return.
For more information about federal taxes go to the IRS web site.
For more information about Louisiana taxes go to the Louisiana Department of Revenue's web
site.
Using an Attorney in Business Planning
Whether a business is started over the kitchen table or is a multi-million dollar high-tech startup,
operating a small business can raise numerous legal and financial questions. Attorneys,
accountants, and other professionals, operating within their professional roles, can provide
information and assistance that is vital to the success of a business enterprise.
For example, the tax effects of starting a business or acquiring a business can be extremely
complex.
- Attorneys usually provide information and advice on how to set up and
operate various business entities and on the application of the tax laws.
- If the business entity involves more than one person, attorneys can draft
agreements that can resolve important questions that might become the subject
of later disagreement among partners or shareholders.
- If an existing business is to be acquired, an attorney can help analyze the
advisability of the various methods of acquiring the business.
- Attorneys can draft important documents protecting the interests of the
buyer and resolve potential disagreements concerning the conclusion of the
transaction.
- In the due diligence phase of a transaction, attorneys gather financial and other
information and can assist in determining the value of the business being
acquired, and the nature of any existing and "contingent liabilities."
In addition, a seller may wish to protect important confidential information from disclosure in
case the transaction fails to occur. This can be done with a confidentiality agreement drafted by
an attorney before the due diligence process begins. Generally, a confidentiality agreement is
appropriate if it is drafted to protect truly confidential information only and serves as a
mechanism by which such information is clearly identified.
Other Useful Web Sites
Other useful web sites for business owners and those considering going
into business are:
InfoLouisiana - This site has all
types of information on it about doing business in Louisiana, as well as
links to other Louisiana State Government pages.
Louisana Department of Revenue and Taxation -
This site has a wealth of information about Louisiana Taxes as well as the
forms necessary for filing of Louisiana tax returns and frequently asked
questions about Louisiana taxes.
Internal Revenue Service -
This site is the official site of the Internal Revenue Service. It has all
types of information about federal income taxes as well as downloadable
forms for filing with the IRS.
Findlaw Small Business Center -
This site has a wealth of general, tax, and legal information for the small
business.
George H. Mills
Attorney At Law
331 Milam Street, Suite 300
Shreveport, Louisiana 71101
(318)222-0337
© 2000-2002 Mills, Turansky, & Griffith -
legal disclaimer
Mills, Turansky, & Griffith
300 Law Center
331 Milam Street, P.O. Box 1784
Shreveport, LA 71166-1784